Why Different Saddle Fitters Provide Different Recommendations

Receiving conflicting advice from different saddle fitters is a common experience for many horse owners and riders. There are several reasons why this occurs, and understanding them can help you make more informed decisions about your horse's comfort and wellbeing. 

The Subjectivity of Saddle Fitting

Saddle fitting is not an exact science; rather, it relies heavily on the fitter's training, experience, and personal philosophy.   Saddle fit is often about problem solving and each fitter may have a unique approach or set of priorities, such as focusing more on the horse's back shape, the rider's position, or the overall balance of the saddle. This subjectivity can naturally lead to differing opinions and recommendations.  Then you have to factor in that the fitters did not see the horse at the same time on the same day so they could be solving a problem with a different set of metrics.

Different Training and Qualifications

Saddle fitters come from various backgrounds and may have received training from different organisations or schools of thought. Some may be qualified through established bodies such as the Society of Master Saddlers, while others might be self-taught or trained on the job. The standards and techniques taught can vary widely, which influences the advice they give.  Their level of experience and expertise can vary greatly as can their knowledge of different brands, trees and panels.

Variety in Saddle Brands and Products

Many saddle fitters work with specific brands or have partnerships with certain manufacturers. This can affect their recommendations, as they may be more familiar with, or have a preference for, particular saddles. Consequently, they might suggest solutions based on what is available in their stock or what they believe works best, even if another fitter prefers a different brand or model.

Another factor that can influence the advice you receive is whether a fitter recommends selling your current saddle if it does not fit, rather than making suitable alterations or adjustments. Some fitters may suggest selling and replacing the saddle outright, especially if they feel that the existing one cannot be safely adapted.  Sometimes a fitter may not possess the necessary knowledge or skills to make suitable or it could be they represent particular brands with alternatives in stock.   Others, however, may focus on suitable adjustments such as changing the flocking, altering the gullet width, or adding shims to make the current saddle work for both horse and rider.   This difference in approach can further contribute to the conflicting guidance you encounter, so it is important to weigh the practical and financial implications of each option before making a decision.

Individual Horse and Rider Combinations

Every horse and rider duo is unique, and there are often several ways to address a fitting issue. One fitter might prioritise the horse’s shoulder freedom, while another focuses on the rider’s balance or the saddle’s panel contact. Both may be correct, but their solutions differ based on which aspect they consider most important.

Assessment Techniques and Tools

Saddle fitters may use different methods to assess fit, such as hands-on palpation, templating, pressure mapping, or even gait analysis. The variation in tools and techniques can lead to different interpretations of what is ‘correct’ or ‘optimal’ for your horse and you as a rider.

Communication and Interpretation

Sometimes, advice might seem conflicting simply due to differences in opinion and how information is explained or understood.  One fitter’s suggestion to ‘try a wider tree’ might complement another’s advice to ‘check the flocking’, but if not communicated clearly, these can appear at odds.

How to Navigate Conflicting Advice

·         Ask Questions: Don’t hesitate to ask each fitter to explain the reasoning behind their recommendations.

·         Seek Evidence: Look for demonstrations or evidence of improved movement or comfort with a particular saddle.

·         Involve your team:  It’s reasonable to have your coach, physio, vet and other professionals work with your fitter to provide that holistic approach, especially for complex cases.

·         Trust Your Observations: You know your horse best; observe how they respond to different saddles and advice.

·         Document Changes: Keep notes or photos to track progress or changes in your horse’s way of going.

Ultimately, conflicting advice is not necessarily a sign of poor practice, but rather a reflection of the complexity and artistry involved in saddle fitting. By staying engaged and informed, you can work with professionals to find the best solution for you and your horse.